Introduction
Over the past decade, during exhibitions and restorations of works by the Venetian painter Jacopo Robusti, known as Tintoretto, numerous archaeometric investigations have been conducted to analyze the conservation state of the master's painting layers. Scholars are now questioning: How appropriate is it to base modern judgments on the dramatic coloration of Tintoretto's works, given that scientific analyses reveal that the deterioration of painting materials has significantly altered the original hues? Consequently, how much of what we see today was intentionally created by the painter, and how much results from chemical alterations that have occurred gradually over the centuries within the paint film?
Spectroscopic Analyses and Pigment Degradation
Non-invasive spectroscopic analyses, such as visible reflectance spectroscopy (vis-RS) and X-ray fluorescence (XRF), have been employed to assess the conservation state of Tintoretto's color schemes. One of the most notable and widespread issues is the degradation of many blue tones. Throughout his career, Robusti utilized and experimented with a broad and varied palette, employing all available blue pigments of the time. Depending on the commission, working conditions, the prestige of the work, or the context, he used pigments of varying quality. Specifically, studies document that Tintoretto employed a full range of blues, from the expensive lapis lazuli to azurite, from the economical smalt to indigo blue.
Smalt, or smalt blue, is a pigment that the master frequently used, as did other contemporary Venetian artists (as demonstrated by recent restorations of Paolo Veronese's painted ceiling in the Church of San Sebastiano in Venice). This pigment is derived from the grinding of potassium sodium glass, to which cobalt is added during production to impart the blue color. In addition to cobalt, its formulation includes other oxides: sodium, aluminum, calcium, iron, nickel, arsenic, and bismuth. Elemental analyses like XRF allow for the identification of the main constituents of the glass and its impurities, enabling precise identification. Since the 1960s, scientific studies have highlighted the alteration process that smalt undergoes when placed in an oil-based medium. Chemically, a reaction occurs between the alkaline nature of the pigment and the acidity of the binding environment (oils contain carboxylic acids), resulting in the saponification of the potassium fatty acids. Additionally, a reaction likely occurs between the potassium glass and the anions present in the color, leading to the production of carbonates and sulfates, which are pollutants. Over time, the potassium in the smalt migrates into the oil, rises to the surface, and causes a general graying of the areas treated with this pigment. Today, smalt-painted areas appear gray, gray-green, or pale brown. It has been speculated that this phenomenon can occur within a century of application. For decades, researchers have investigated the causes of these reactions between pigment and binder. It has been observed that in some paintings, marginal areas covered by varnish and thus shielded from light exposure have been preserved, suggesting that light plays a definitive role in the degradation of smalt blue. It is essential to understand that the current appearance of Tintoretto's works does not match what his contemporaries would have seen. The paintings appeared more vibrant, and many of the blues that Robusti generously applied, especially in backgrounds and landscapes, are now missing.
Indigo can be recognized through vis-RS examination, as its fundamental component, indigotin, has a characteristic absorption band. The Venetian master used indigo alone or for finishing touches. Azurite, present in high-quality works like The Miracle of the Slave in the Gallerie dell’Accademia, is found in many of his paintings, especially early ones. It has been noted that a significant number of early paintings contain azurite, which was less expensive than lapis lazuli and thus more accessible for a painter at the beginning of his career. Spectroscopic examinations show that Tintoretto often mixed different qualities of blue together to achieve iridescent and luminous effects, most of which are now lost. This is also the case in The Theft of the Body of St. Mark, housed in the Gallerie dell’Accademia and originating from the Scuola Grande di San Marco. The sky that today's observer perceives as yellow, brown, and at times gray is the result of the discoloration of paint layers containing smalt and azurite. It was not a dark, stormy sky but a blue one, rendered livid by the mixture of blues with black. In the same painting, however, Tintoretto used lapis lazuli of great purity for the robes of the thieves, applied with drying oil. In large-scale works, such as the apsidal canvases of the Church of Madonna dell'Orto in Venice, the artist used the most expensive blues only for the garments of the most iconographically and compositionally significant figures, while indigo and smalt were used for the sky and water, i.e., for the vast areas of landscape filling. These bluish areas, with luminous reflections that we can only imagine, are now perceived as brown or gray. The current interpretation of these works, as well as many others, is misled by the chemical alterations that have occurred. The chromatic drama that certain authors note in the majority of Tintoretto's canvases was not intentional.
Alterations in Other Colors
However, it is not only the blue colors that have radically changed appearance over time. In addition to the yellowed or grayed blues, today's viewer must consider two other significant chromatic transformations: red lakes have darkened to become brown-violet, and copper resinate has blackened to the point of losing all brilliance. Analyses have examined the greens, all copper-based, which have turned dark brown due to alteration products. Malachite, verdigris, and copper resinate could not be detected with XRF but were identified through stratigraphic analyses under a microscope. Under optical microscopy, thin sections of green areas show that over time, a dark patina has formed, covering the original bright green layer. As the son of a dyer, Robusti was undoubtedly well-versed in the world of textile dyes that made Venice an economic hub for centuries. The red lakes used by Tintoretto are varied, including madder lake. These dyes are highly photosensitive and, over the decades, lose their intensity and brilliance, eventually appearing, as they do today, dark violet or brown.
Bibliography
Sara Abram (ed.), La Crocifissione di Tintoretto. L'intervento sul dipinto dei Musei civici di Padova, Editris 2000, Turin, 2013. Within this work, Gianluca Poldi's essay also analyzes the results of investigations conducted on about ten restored works during the exhibition Tintoretto, curated by Vittorio Sgarbi, presented to the public at the Scuderie del Quirinale between February 25 and June 10, 2012.
Grazia Fumo, Dino Chinellato (eds.), Tintoretto svelato. Il soffitto della Sala dell’Albergo nella Scuola Grande di San Rocco. Storie ricerche, restauri, Milan, Skira, 2010.
Joyce Plester, Lorenzo Lazzarini, I materiali e la tecnica del Tintoretto della Scuola Grande di San Rocco, in Paola Rossi, Lionello Puppi, Jacopo Tintoretto nel quarto centenario dalla morte, proceedings of the international study conference (Venice, November 24–26, 1994).
Joyce Plester, Lorenzo Lazzarini, The examination of the Tintorettos, in Ashley Clarke, Philip Rylands, Restoring Venice: The Church of the Madonna dell'Orto, London, 1997, pp. 84–92.
Gianluca Poldi, Giovanni Carlo Federico Villa, Dalla conservazione alla storia dell’arte. Riflettografia e analisi non invasive per lo studio dei dipinti, Edizione Della Normale, Pisa, 2007, pp. 157–158.
Gianluca Poldi, Gli azzurri perduti nei dipinti di Tintoretto. Ri-vedere le cromie grazie alle analisi scientifiche, in Abram, La Crocifissione di Tintoretto… cit., pp. 101–114.
For special visits, for specific requests, for a tour in unusual places, but also to give a guided tour as a gift to someone, feel free to contact me.
We can plan the best experience together!
CONTACT ME